What varies house to house is not neighbourhood quality but which catchment an address falls into, and that boundary can put two houses a few blocks apart into different school assignments even within the same neighbourhood, sometimes changing every 2 to 3 years as capacity shifts.
Established areas like Nutana and Varsity View sit near long-running schools with decades of enrolment history, while newer areas like Brighton and Aspen Ridge are still building out school capacity as the population grows, so the tradeoff is history against newer facilities rather than one side simply being better.
Joel Dyck can check the current catchment for any specific address before you decide. Get your hand-reviewed valuation from Joel Dyck.