School catchment boundaries matter more to most families than a neighbourhood's general reputation, since two houses a few blocks apart can feed different schools, and that detail is worth confirming directly rather than assuming from the address alone.
Distance to a grocery store, a park and a family doctor tends to matter just as much day to day as the school question, and those distances vary house to house within any neighbourhood, Mayfair included.
The right way to judge fit is against your own family's specific routine, not a general label. Get your hand-reviewed valuation from Joel Dyck.