Condition matters more here than the street address, because renovation quality varies widely from house to house in Caswell Hill's older housing stock. A well-updated character home draws strong interest from buyers who specifically want that heritage feel, while a home with deferred maintenance competes on price rather than character.
Because the neighbourhood's appeal is tied to its character homes, an accurate valuation depends on knowing what has actually been updated inside a specific house, not just its age or street. Public records rarely capture that level of detail for older housing stock.
Knowing your home's real condition-adjusted value is the starting point either way. Get your hand-reviewed valuation from Joel Dyck.