The right comparison starts with how each neighbourhood is actually used day to day: proximity to schools and parks, commute direction into the city, and the age and style of housing stock you will find on the ground, since the Saskatchewan REALTORS Association tracks both as distinct areas that vary block to block more than a single label suggests.
Resale strength in either area comes down to condition and improvements more than the neighbourhood name. A well-maintained home with documented upgrades competes on its own merits against the Saskatoon benchmark of $444,700, regardless of which of the two streets it sits on.
Neither an online estimate nor a public assessment record can tell you which of the two suits your commute, your school catchment or your resale plan five years out. Get your hand-reviewed valuation from Joel Dyck.